OK, you may already have gotten your nice red government $40 gift rebate coupon for a DTV digital to Analog converter just in case you don't intend to shell out a wad for a new large screen digital TV and made the conversion already. If so, you may be wasting your time reading this post. Anyway, about a month and a half ago, I decided it might be time to see if we could get any digital signal at all using our off-air antennas and do it before there was no analog signal to even use as a test. I sent in an order for the coupons...and waited.
Local Pamida had a $99 sale price on a 13 inch Sansui Digital tuner TV set...think it was DTV-1300. So in a weak moment a week or so ago, I bought one just to check what happened with getting digital off air instead of via cable or satellite. At a house on a hill in Winner, we have only an amplified rabbit ear antenna. The 13-inch digital Sansui had a good analog picture on Public TV channel 10, KELOLAND channel 6, and KSFY on channel 4, and it found some of the digital signals when the digital channel scan was run, but it would only signal a "weak signal" error message and would not display any of the digital channels.
I took the set out to our farm house where I have a good antenna in the attic pointed toward Reliance about 40 miles away. I also have an amplifier on a good antenna pointed toward Bassett, Nebraska which will bring in an analog signal from there..not as good a signal however. I don't use that very often because SDPB started broadcasting Charlie Rose show again and I did not have to watch it on Nebraska. In any case, the 13 inch Sansui would not bring in any digital signals from either antenna or if I used the amplifier with the antenna in the direction of Reliance.
I did not know anybody around here pulling in a digital signal via an antenna, so I started trying to find information again. Most sites are more or less fronts for some marketing system and I found little useful information, but one site did indicate that if you could get a good analog signal, the digital signal should work and have a better picture. After a day or two of wasting time trying to find more information, I called SDPB and got a chance to talk to Dale Baity? who is engineer with SDPB in Rapid City. He suggested I cut all signal splitters and switches out of the antenna lines since the can cause significant signal losses with a splitter effectively cutting signal in half. He remembered that a fellow I knew about 15 or 20 miles further away from the transmitters near Reliance, SD was able to get a digital signal. He provided me with more information as well.... all interesting and some useful.
I knew the guy he mentioned and called and talked to him. He had sets getting the digital signal and said images were much better than any analog he was getting before.
The next morning, our $40 coupons for the converters finally arrived. I bought a Digital Stream converter at the local Nelson Radio Shack store. Hooked it up in town between the rabbit ears and the set and then did the channel scan and in a few minutes, was watching SDPB digital images on an analog set. Pamida agreed to allow me to return the Sansui set. I don't know if the particular set had a defective digital tuner or amplifier, or if it is just a mediocre design that is in all those sets. Stores selling digital TV sets might want to do a little testing with an outdoor antenna to see if any or all models work with off the air signals in their locality.
I bought a Philco converter at Karl's TV and brought it out to the farm. With very little fuss, I had KSFY, SDPB, and KPLO coming in via the antenna with digital signals converted to analog for our old set.
In short, the process of moving from off-the-air analog signals to digital using antennas rather than cable or satellite is not terribly complex, but not quite as simple as the information ads you see on TV either. It does appear however that if you can get a good analog signal, you should also be able to get a good enough digital signal to use a digital to analog converter with your analog set and have a good picture. In fact, the picture using the converted digital signal is likely to be much better with no snow and also not showing some of the interference that comes in with analog signals.
Apparently there is a "digital precipice" for signals. You either get a good digital image or none at all. Analog signals on analog sets can give varying qualities of images depending on distance and terrain with the image quality likely to just gradually fall off into a world of snow even if audio is still present as well. Even though the Sansu set got no useful digital signal, the signal strength indicators for all channels using the converters were in the green "best" area.
In a followup post, I will add some information on the converters with a few photos comparing analog and digital signals as they are seen on an analog set. One bit of information however. Despite sales clerks telling you all of the converters are all the same, that is not quite true. The menu systems and the handheld remote tuners can be very different as well as whether functions are only determined by a menu or a combination of menus and switches. Also the lowest price versions may not have "analog pass through" which may be helpful until February 2009 and the analog pass through may work better on some converters than others.
Also, if you think you may continue to use your analog sets past February, 2009 with digital to analog converters, you may want to start on the conversion sooner rather than later. Availability of the converters seems to be rather variable depending on stores and chains and which suppliers they use. Yesterday, none were available in Rapid City at Sam's Club, Walmart, and perhaps other stores. Pamida was out of them here. Karl's had a few left and Radio Shack may have one or two left and are waiting for more. Estimates are that something like 15% of the population still relies on analog signals and does not have cable or satellite. That is a lot of converters or new digital sets which must work with off-air signals.
** Stay tuned even if you are tuned in digitally already and wonder what the fuss is about--- Doug Wiken
Recent Comments